The Dietitian's Office

Picky, Picky, Picky: What To Make When Nobody Seems to Want To Eat.

Nov 29, 2022
We all have our go-to’s and favorites when it comes to foods. But what to do when whole food groups have disappeared from the acceptable list? If it seems like all kinds of foods have made the “naughty list,”...

We all have our go-to’s and favorites when it comes to foods. But what to do when whole food groups have disappeared from the acceptable list? If it seems like all kinds of foods have made the “naughty list,” what can we do to bring back some variety into our family’s diet?

First, let’s tackle some of the pickiest eaters in the house, Kids. One of the MOST challenging issues when it comes to eating a well-rounded diet can be dealing with a limited or “picky” palate.

There Are Two Basic “Rules” For Feeding Your Child

  1. You decide what, when, and where to feed your child
  2. Your child decides how and whether to eat

If your child is healthy and eating a nutritious and varied diet, this is the most important point. If your child is healthy and eats a nutritious and varied diet, yet seems to eat very little, he or she may simply need less food energy (calories) than other children. This is ok. And some children need more daily calories than others the same age or size, and they eat more than you might expect. Every child has different calorie needs.

Picky, Picky, Picky: What To Make When Nobody Seems to Want To Eat.

To avoid a power struggle at meals, it can be helpful to think about the what, where, and when of eating.

What

  • Work with what your child likes
  • Provide a variety of nutritious foods for children, at reasonably timed meals and at the dinner table
  • Example: Pizza can be prepared with a variety of vegetables used as sauce and added as toppings
  • Allow your child to select which foods to eat from among those you have provided.
  • If your child only wants to eat one type of food, he or she is doing the parent’s job of deciding what food choices are. It is the parent’s job to decide what foods are offered.
  • Cut down on any drinks that contain calories like soda pop and other high-sugar drinks, juice or milk between meals.
  • Let your child decide when he or she is finished eating.

As a sub- comment: Stay out of these decisions (avoid the clean plate club).

If you are worried about food waste- offer smaller portions with greater variety and then allow for seconds when your child is still hungry.

Where

  • Make family meals to be pleasant social events
  • Emphasize the social aspects of special events like birthdays and holidays vs the foods offered
  • Avoid using food as an independent reward
  • Eat at a table in a calm distraction free space

Remember food is about more than just fuel or just satisfaction!

When

  • Making sure that you child is actually HUNGRY when the meal is presented can go a long way towards them accepting new or previously avoided foods
  • Make mealtimes predictable. Eat at around the same times every day and always at the table, even for snacks.
  • Set up your family for success- make time in the schedule for eating meals- at least 30-60 min and prioritize this time.

Putting all this into practice can be difficult, so tackle a few at a time. Select 1 or 2 of the habits listed above that you feel you (or your family ) could grow into, and focus there. When you have that down, move on to another skill to build.

If budget is a barrier to getting a variety of foods in the house, there are a variety of programs to help you access good, nutritious foods. Working with a dietitian can help you identify programs and services you may qualify for, as well as help boost your cooking confidence. We can help with shopping, cooking, and eating the right kinds of foods. Very basic cooking classes can get you the skills and confidence to try new foods yourself.

Remember, when working on making meals healthier, it can sometimes seem like it’s all about the family and their needs. If you are the primary meal preparer in the house, it’s important to care for yourself and sustain your curiosity and zeal for this everyday task. Make it fun for you too! New cookbooks, social media feeds, or even trying a new restaurant can spark your interest in new foods and rekindle a love for foods you didn’t even know existed.